Academic Essays / Area of Research

Corruption Outside and Inside Nick’s Retrospective Narration in The Great Gatsby

Literary analysis

Sara Wan · 2,559 words in the essay

12 May 2026

Set in Prohibition-era New York, The Great Gatsby presents a world whose glamour depends on illegal money and spectacle. Fitzgerald uses Nick’s retrospective narration to make his account feel authoritative and to shape the reader’s moral response to Gatsby. Fitzgerald does not expose that world through an all-knowing narrator; instead, he filters it through Nick, a narrator who writes after Gatsby’s death and therefore has control over the order and moral tones of the events readers learn. Because he does so, his narration heighten certain details while delaying others, sorting people into categories. As a result, the novel exposes corruption on two levels at once; it reveals the overt criminal world of secrecy and fraud surrounding Gatsby, but it also reveals the subtler corruption and subjectivity within Nick’s own voice. Through Nick’s retrospective narration, Fitzgerald reveals Gatsby’s criminal world and exposes how Nick’s selective judgment, complicity, and ethnic prejudice make the narrator morally compromised rather than neutral.

Retrospective narration matters because Nick never delivers the past in the same order he first lived it. He writes after Gatsby’s death, after Myrtle’s death, and after his self-reflection on incompatibility with the East, so every early description is colored by knowledge he has control over. Fitzgerald reveals that control in the opening pages. Nick claims he is “inclined to reserve all judgments,” yet almost immediately interrupts himself to declare that “Only Gatsby, the man who gives his name to this book, was exempt from [his] reaction” and that Gatsby “turned out all right at the end” (Fitzgerald 1-2). Those early contradictions matter because they plant Nick’s verdict before the evidence appears. He also does something similar with Gatsby’s identity, where he delays the truth about Gatsby’s tragedy until the novel has already made Gatsby into a spectacle and rumor. Fitzgerald uses that delay to show that Nick’s retrospective narration is not a memoir of Gatsby, but at the same time a staged design to expose the underside of Gatsby. He lets readers suspect Gatsby before they understand him and pity Gatsby before they know how much he has lied. Once that structure is clear, Nick’s mischievous narration becomes part of the argument of the novel itself. Fitzgerald presents a novel about corruption in the 1920s, but with a stronger intention to show how Nick, a retrospective narrator, arranges that corruption into a story about morality.

Nick’s retrospective narration first shapes Gatsby as a criminal possibility before it allows Gatsby to become more complex. At the beginning of the novel, Nick presents himself as someone “inclined to reserve all judgments” and claims that “reserving judgments is a matter of infinite hope” (Fitzgerald 1). Because he narrates from hindsight, this self-presentation is a strategic pose that encourages readers to trust a narrator who already knows how the story ends. At Gatsby’s parties, Nick writes about guests repeating that Gatsby “killed a man” and that he is “a bootlegger” (Fitzgerald 61). Nick does not interrupt those rumors, and he does not correct them later; he lets readers trust the suspicion he creates as they become the reader’s first impression. Nick lets the rumors stand because he already knows Gatsby’s reputation is not innocent, and wants suspicion to become the reader’s first impression. He deepens that impression during the drive to New York, when Gatsby “hurried the phrase ‘educated at Oxford,’ or swallowed it, or choked on it, as though it had bothered him before” (Fitzgerald 65). Nick could simply report Gatsby’s claim, but instead, he highlights the loophole in Gatsby’s performance. Nick could have summarized Gatsby’s self-introduction plainly and accepted it as it was, but instead, he focuses on the hesitation in Gatsby’s speech and invites the reader to suspect fraud. That suspicion becomes more meaningful within the historical world of the novel. As Antonios Eleftherakis argues, Prohibition and the illegal alcohol trade are central to Fitzgerald’s portrait of the Roaring Twenties, so Gatsby’s success belongs to a broader culture of bootlegging and secrecy rather than honest self-making (Eleftherakis 3). In that context, Nick’s retrospective narration does not invent suspicion out of nowhere; it frames Gatsby within a world where suspicion already makes social and historical sense. Maureen Corrigan’s reading of the novel as noir-like sharpens Fitzgerald’s intention of making illegal trade a big part of how Nick understands Gatsby, and Nick’s retrospective voice helps create that effect because it casts Gatsby’s rise in an atmosphere of danger from the start. Fitzgerald therefore uses retrospective narration not merely to tell Gatsby’s story after the fact, but to stage the reader’s discovery so that the brilliance of Gatsby’s world will look like it rests on a criminal foundation.

Nick’s control over the story becomes even clearer when the narration turns toward his own conduct. As a retrospective narrator, he does not explain everything exactly as it happened; instead, he decides what to disclose and what to blur. Fitzgerald uses that freedom to make Nick’s vagueness meaningful. The most telling example appears in the scene with Mr. McKee. After Nick follows Tom and Myrtle to the Manhattan apartment, the narration suddenly leaps through ellipses into a sexually suggestive and deliberately confusing moment: “...I was standing beside his bed, and he was sitting up between the sheets, clad in his underwear” (Fitzgerald 37). The scene ends almost as abruptly as it begins. Nick does not explain what happened, how he got there, or why the episode matters. Because he is looking back, that omission cannot be dismissed as simple confusion; it is a later choice he intends to display. Nick writes as someone who has already decided which parts of the past deserve clarity and which can remain foggy, and that control is the privilege of retrospective narration. Nick edits the moment at the point where a full explanation might expose him, and the elevator boy’s command to “keep your hands off the lever” sharpens the scene’s charged awkwardness and social risk surrounding the encounter (Fitzgerald 37). Nick wants the authority of a morally serious witness, so when his own behavior becomes embarrassing or socially risky, his voice turns evasive. Fitzgerald uses that evasiveness to suggest that the culture of secrecy in the novel is not confined to bootleggers and adulterers; it shapes the narrator’s voice as well.

Nick’s moral compromise also appears in the difference between the judgments he pronounces and the actions he chooses in the moment. Because he narrates retrospectively, Nick can turn his past involvement into present moral commentary. Fitzgerald uses that split to show that Nick is not simply an observer of corruption but one of its enablers. Nick arranges Daisy and Gatsby’s reunion even though he knows Daisy is married and understands Gatsby’s romantic purpose. When the meeting begins, he admits, “I made an excuse at the first possible moment and got to my feet,” deliberately leaving them alone (Fitzgerald 87). He also accompanies Tom and Myrtle to the New York apartment despite knowing Tom is conducting an affair. Later, Nick condemns Tom and Daisy as “careless people” who “smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money” (Fitzgerald 179). The judgment is retrospectively self-exonerating: in the moment, Nick helps the immorality he later condemns. Although Nick’s later judgments sound morally sharp, they also reveal his selectiveness. He finds Tom’s secrecy enraging, and Tom is a “careless,” and “money-driven creature” (Fitzgerald 179), while Gatsby’s secrecy often appears to him as romantic or pitiable, rendering Gatsby “exempt from [his] reaction” (Fitzgerald 2). Fitzgerald uses that inconsistency to show that Nick’s perspective is ethically unstable. Nick is not an objective observer standing outside the novel’s corruption; rather, he is a participant who carries guilt and damage. Corrigan notes that Nick’s voice works like a noir voice-over, a voice that sorts the past into guilt and damage after the worst has already happened (Corrigan 129). That pattern matters because Nick’s retrospective narration reveals corruption in the 1920s while also revealing his need to place himself above the behavior he once chose to move within. The older Nick writes as if later clarity can cleanse earlier participation, but by the time he names Tom and Daisy “careless,” he has already spent the novel carrying invitations, arranging meetings, and serving as the respectable witness who helps other people’s misconduct move forward (Fitzgerald 179). Fitzgerald makes that temporal split visible so that Nick’s judgment never looks fully innocent.

Nick’s admiration and extraordinary sympathy for Gatsby further reveal the limits of his neutrality. Retrospective narration allows Nick to shape Gatsby after death, and Fitzgerald uses that power to reveal both Nick’s tenderness and his bias. Near the end of the novel, Nick tries to justify this subjectivity by insisting that he “disapproved of [Gatsby] from beginning to end” (Fitzgerald 154), but that claim does not match the language he uses throughout the book. On the second page, Nick already admits that “there was something gorgeous about [Gatsby]” (Fitzgerald 2). This early admission marks Gatsby as morally exceptional before the reader has seen the full extent of his lies and criminal ties. Additionally, as Gatsby waits outside Daisy’s house after Myrtle’s death, Nick confesses, “[Gatsby] was clutching at some last hope and I couldn’t bear to shake him free” (Fitzgerald 148). The key phrase is “couldn’t bear.” Because Nick narrates Gatsby’s story after his death, his sympathy helps shape Gatsby into a tragic figure whose longing overshadows his criminality. Nick does not merely understand Gatsby; he protects him from the full force of reality, and then he narrates that protection as if it were compassion rather than complicity. Indeed, after Gatsby dies, Nick becomes the only major character to find Gatsby’s death deserving of a funeral as he searches for mourners. His loyalty is moving, but it also shapes the novel’s moral emphasis. Fitzgerald gives Nick this retrospective sympathy for a reason – that is, if Gatsby were presented only as a bootlegger and fraud, he would remain one more criminal in a corrupt decade. Nick’s affection turns him into something larger and sadder, a figure whose criminality is inseparable from longing. Nick’s bias shows that retrospective narration in the novel does not preserve objective fact; it actively constructs Gatsby as the tragic moral center of the story. Nick turns Gatsby from a shady bootlegger into the tragic center of the book, and that transformation reveals the narrator’s own emotional investment.

The subtler corruption in Nick’s voice becomes clearest when he describes ethnicity. Peter Gregg Slater argues that Nick’s “ethnic consciousness” is built into the perspective of the novel itself rather than added from outside (Slater 55). Fitzgerald supports that claim most powerfully through Meyer Wolfsheim. When Nick introduces Wolfsheim, he does not present Wolfsheim merely as Gatsby’s business partner but describes him as a “small, flat-nosed Jew,” lingering over the stereotypical Jewish outer appearance in a way that makes him appear simultaneously exotic and suspicious (Fitzgerald 69). Other characters like Tom, who carry the same ethnicity as Nick, are never described in the same exotic way. By contrast, Tom is described as “sturdy” and as having “a great pack of muscle,” which lets him stand as a physical norm rather than an exotic or suspicious figure (Fitzgerald 7). The difference in description matters because it shows how Nick’s judgments are embedded in habit as well as in explicit moral statements. Even when he is not openly condemning anyone, his language sorts people of his own ethnicity into the sturdy norm, while those of other ethnicities are exotic and suspect.

A smaller example appears when he refers to his housekeeper as a “Finn” instead of by name (Fitzgerald 84). That detail is brief, but it supports the larger pattern of judging by ethnicity. The Finnish housekeeper is only referred to in relation to her nationality and role, not by her name (Slater 55). Retrospective narration sharpens this point because these descriptions show how Nick has had time to select, polish, and shape his written account, yet he keeps the ethnic labels in place. The prejudice is therefore not a natural dialogue that stems from the pressure of the moment, but part of the record he chooses to write about and leave behind. Fitzgerald therefore shows that the moral damage of the 1920s is not limited to illegal acts such as bootlegging or adultery, as it also appears in the habits of perception through which respectable people imagine other people. Nick can detect corruption in Gatsby’s parties, Tom’s affair, and Daisy’s carelessness, yet his own narration still carries the prejudice of the world he claims to judge. Corruption, therefore, appears not only in the novel’s events but also in Nick’s own habits of evaluation.

Nick’s final chapters make the retrospective structure of the novel fully visible. After Gatsby’s death, Nick becomes the person who must call former guests, contact Wolfsheim, and arrange the funeral, only to discover how quickly Gatsby’s glamorous world disappears once there is no spectacle left to consume. The emptiness around the funeral exposes the hollowness of the social order Nick has been narrating all along. Because he tells the story from the aftermath, Nick can convert a series of parties, affairs, and rumors into a larger moral verdict on the decade. Corrigan’s noir reading helps explain why the novel ends this way, highlighting that when Nick has the choice to conclude with social restoration, he chooses to emphasize the fallout and portray a narrator trying to make meaning out of damage that cannot be repaired (Corrigan 130). Retrospective narration also explains why the novel ends with this specific interpretation rather than social restoration. Once Gatsby dies, the facts are finished; what remains is Nick’s effort to impose pattern on them. Near the end, he insists that this has been “a story of the West, after all” and that he, Gatsby, Daisy, Tom, and Jordan are all “Westerners” who are “subtly unadaptable to Eastern life” (Fitzgerald 176). The claim broadens the book’s moral from individual spectacle to critiquing the culture, but it also shows Nick still revising the past in order to restore moral order. He reclassifies the whole experience as regional and cultural so that the East can be responsible for the damaged moral atmosphere. However, Fitzgerald makes that gesture only partly convincing; Nick can condemn the East, but he cannot narrate it without exposing how deeply it has shaped his values, loyalties, and prejudices. The retrospective form, therefore, completes the novel’s multilayered critique of revealing both Gatsby’s criminal world and the compromised narrator who tries to explain that world afterward.

By filtering Gatsby’s rise and fall through Nick’s retrospective narration, Fitzgerald exposes corruption on two levels at once. Gatsby’s world is openly criminal, built on bootlegging, rumor, and violence, yet the novel’s deeper unease comes from Nick himself. Because the book is written after a catastrophe, every memory Nick offers is already an interpretation. His evasions, selective sympathy, participation in other people’s affairs, and racialized descriptions show that he has a choice to be a neutral witness standing above the story but is inevitably shaped by the same values he condemns. Fitzgerald therefore critiques more than gangsters or careless elites; he suggests that corruption has entered the habits of judgment and perception themselves. In the end, Nick’s voice does more than tell Gatsby’s tragedy; it reveals how deeply the values of the 1920s have compromised the narrator who tries to explain them.

Works Cited

Corrigan, Maureen. So We Read On: How The Great Gatsby Came to Be and Why It Endures. Little, Brown and Company, 2014.

Eleftherakis, Antonios. The Roaring Twenties as Depicted in Scott Fitzgerald’s “The Great Gatsby.” University of Piraeus (Greece), 2022. ProQuest.

Fitzgerald, F. Scott. The Great Gatsby. Scribner, 2004.

Slater, Peter Gregg. “Ethnicity in The Great Gatsby.” Twentieth Century Literature, vol. 19, no. 1, 1973, pp. 53–62. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/440797.