Academic Essays / Area of Research

The History We Make of

Literary analysis

Sara Wan · 2,191 words in the essay

On the island of Alcatraz, two young sisters watch a protest collapse into hunger and grief. Decades later, one of them teaches her grandsons to survive by silence. Through this cycle, Tommy Orange shows how the Native history of characters in There There is relived, how each carrier of history decides what to remake. There There refuses a single, “monolithic,” image of Native life; instead, it narrates the urban Native experience where memory, continuity, and invention coexist (Beckerman). The factor of historical trauma in There There complicates characters’ interpretation of history and what meanings they can safely make from it. The novel exposes how inherited pain within the urban Native life generates new expressions and understandings of cultural continuity, proving that Native identity persists in novel adaptation, rather than traditional purity.

To understand how this theme unfolds in the novel, we can begin with one of its most defining forces: historical trauma. Historical trauma is one of the most prevalent themes in There There that involves the generational weight of inherited pain from the past. These emotions are passed down through multiple generations, shaping how the following generations see themselves and the world, and how it influences their naming of it.

Opal and Jacquie, for instance, begin their stories at Alcatraz, where their mother, being on the verge of eviction at their old house in Oakland, carries them to join a Native protest that aims to reclaim land and pride. Opal and Jacquie’s first lesson in “belonging” comes here, where survival sets the terms. Orange writes, “There was no house or life to go back to, no hope that maybe [they] would get what we were asking for, that the government would have mercy on us” (Orange 57). This early rupture defines how Opal, as a grandmother, now raises her grandsons; she is protective and avoidant of teaching them about native history, fearing that the same pain of her past will repeat itself. For Opal, history becomes less a source of pride and more of a lesson that should be taken with caution, proving how inherited pain can distort what remembrance can mean to the current.

Tony Loneman, similarly, carries the same challenge of inherited pain, where he carries his pain, fetal alcohol syndrome, literally on his face; “The Drome” is a physical reminder that his pain started before he was even born, noting that “the Drome is [his] mom and why she drank, it’s the way history lands on a face” (16). Tony's line confirms that to him, inherited pain is phenotype; the forced bad decision simply had "landed" on him as a visible stigma that shapes his self-perception and plays a huge role in how others perceive him. However, with a forced outlook, Tony's persistent interiority resists a rather victim narrative, illustrating how individuality and adaptation can flow within constraints.

Orange so makes moral judgment more difficult because "history" plays a factor in every action and choice is never pristine. In these ways, Orange highlights his characters as carriers of history that have not just occurred or followed with pride, but instead how they are understood with difficulty and serve as inherited pain that is adapted in the insides and on the outsides of people.

This pattern of inherited pain is highlighted through Sherman Alexie’s “Indian Education,” where the narrator marks each year of schooling with a new and heavier layer of humiliation and loss, including being “buried into the snow” until he couldn’t breathe, demonstrating a terrible lesson the society seems to teach him of hierarchy in race (Alexie). Then, the experience of watching his father drinking “a gallon of vodka,” highlights the convenient stress relief method within the urban Native community (Alexie). Further, he is then consistently thrown under stereotypes such as being one of the “Indian kids” who start “drinking real young” (Alexie). Alexie’s protagonist echoes Orange’s characters, enduring the pain and bullying from just inheriting the skin of ancestors, poverty of only being able to live off “canned beef that even the dogs wouldn’t eat,” and the weight of his parents’ struggle with addiction: which, to him, struggling with this situation is another “way to starve” (Alexie). Deeply personal but widely communal, historical trauma in the native community is a collective legacy of forced acceptance of difficult factors left behind by the families before them.

Further, Tommy Orange explains in his interview with Beckerman, he wrote There There to resist the “monolithic version of what a Native is supposed to be” (Beckerman). Here, Orange explains that his characters are not the typical “symbolic warriors” or “romanticized figures” of the native Indian community but rather the living results of trauma who are still trying to understand to heal themselves from it (Beckerman). Together, Orange and Alexie reveal that Native identity is not built from unbroken tradition but from the fragments left by historical violence. Through the endurance and survival of those fractures, the characters transform inherited pain into an act of identity itself, complicating the characters’ understanding of history.

In Oakland, far from the traditional lands and ceremonies of the native, characters can be seen consistently navigating an urban city saturated with poverty, addiction, and fractured families. Yet it is within this disconnection that new forms of belonging emerge. Edwin, for instance, searches for his father by utilizing resources such as the internet, his online messages echoing a modernized form of native ceremony, attempting to bridge the absence of his family through modern utilities such as technology. Simultaneously, Orvil Red Feather, with his grandmother’s intentional avoidance of exposing him to native culture, explores the Native culture of dance not from elders but from “watching Youtube videos,” and secretly trying on “the regalia…in front of the full length mirror of Opal’s closet door,” finding his authentic place through virtual puzzles and authentic Indian clothing as he discovers the fragments of culture he was denied (121). This is novel adaptation: these characters, given the circumstances of urban void, drugs, violence, and family fractures, are surviving but more so learning to create meaning out of the fragments provided by modern technology and resources, thereby creating continuity through adaptation rather than replication of their elders and the traditional purity of land access and rituals that had long gone in history.

In many ways, my own search for belonging parallels this struggle. Growing up in China but educated by the American system, I often felt like I belonged to either culture, knowing I felt too Chinese for some, and too American for others. Like Edwin and Orvil, I turned to screens to understand my culture, knowing I was not failing a purity test but practicing novel adaptation, using screens and family stories to convert fracture into belonging. I watch Chinese immigration movies, YouTube clips of language and festivals, digital fragments that stitched together a sense of home. I discuss my understanding of my identity with similar peers and listen to the stories of the elderly in my family. I often find myself comparing their culture with mine, whose experiences helped me realize, much like the characters in There There, that identity isn’t about fitting a fixed image of authenticity but about forming connections in the spaces where the lines of culture have been blurred. For both Orange’s characters and me, the internet, like the culture of the city, becomes a bridge where a loss of traditionality evolves into my own interpretation of new ways of belonging, knowing I don’t necessarily have to be stereotypically authentic, but rather I am authentic in the way carrying the multiple identities and experiences I have navigated through.

This tension between stereotype and modern survival methods mirrors James Luna’s essay “I’ve Always Wanted to Be an American Indian,” where he writes about the gap between the traditional, well-known fantasies of Native life and the lived reality of contemporary communities. Luna first rejects the idea of fantasized Indian culture by listing the status within the reservation, of “diabetes…murders…deaths…cancer…unemployment rates” (Luna). Luna here, dismantles the purity metric and insists on truthful endurance as the measure of identity, using stark comparisons through pejoratives and laudatory: “pain and happiness… success and failure… despair and hope,” insisting that “this is it… the reality that we Indians live,” to expose that his reservation life is filled with a variety of feelings, reminding readers that their lives are not the romanticized image of the stereotypical “beads of many colors” (Luna). Luna, utilizing the striking images of the reservation, recalibrates the rejection of “glory that people culturally hungry want” (Luna). That is precisely what Orange means when he resists the “monolithic version of what a Native is supposed to be” (Beckerman).

Luna, like Orange, encourages readers to emphasize the true colors of the “reality that [they] Indians live,” asserting that modern Native identity cannot be measured by traditional purity but by realities of endurance given by the modern society as it shifts gradually throughout time (Luna). Identity persists where lives persist, and this culture, now with new forms, was not what it used to be.

Cultural continuity is reimagined and made to survive in the spaces where traditional forms have fractured in There There. Opal and Jacquie’s childhood was marked by a forced exposure to Native activism at Alcatraz, where they were too young to understand its purpose but old enough to carry its trauma. Years later, Opal teaches her grandsons about being Native through care and survival rather than traditions and ceremony, fearing the risk of bringing brutal truths to light. Having the superstition of “the sense that there are holes everywhere,” and “cracks you can slip between,” reflects her cautious nature in education, fearing mistakes of harmful exposure to her grandsons in this porous world (160). In this instruction, she balances the idea of continuity by transforming the idea of cultural education from ritual to resilience.

Furthermore, at the Oakland powwow, dozens of people with Native roots gather in the same space, of dancers and of strangers, of “reservations and cities,” from “rancherias, forts, pueblos…,” everyone embodying a version of belonging that is partial, yet real (134). The powwow gathering does not return these individuals to a historic celebration, but instead gathers the present tense of continuity, the dancers eager to show their work while the audience is here to support and learn more about their culture, because of the need of “a place to be together”; identity, now, is not defined by a stereotypical historic act but rather the courage of bringing new offerings (135).

Orvil’s journey, again, epitomizes this new form of adaptation. With no elders to guide him, he learns Native dance from YouTube videos, reconstructing belonging through a digital archive. His education is self-taught and creative, proof that continuity can exist through the adaptations as a present tense of survival, just requiring a sense of sincerity and curiosity, not imitation of the past. This mirrors the narrator of Sherman Alexie’s “Indian Education,” who grows up within a system designed to erase his identity, yet still finds a way to graduate and name himself “valedictorian.” Both Orvil and Alexie’s narrator use their novel understandings of inheritance to reclaim the right to define what inheritance really means. The survival of these traditions in them is their own novel adaptation to interpret themselves to an identity that tried to exclude them.

I see echoes of this in my own life. My grandmother’s generation, different from my own, carries tradition in ways I cannot fully replicate or mimic, ranging from language all the way to rituals shaped by China - then carried by people like her, whose traditions no longer exist. Like Gertrude Stein’s quote in Beckerman, to me, “There is no there there” (Beckerman). The land my grandparents walked on, parallel to Orange’s answer to Beckerman, “has been [land] developed over and unrecognizable,” which is my answer as well, because my generation and the ones that are coming will navigate our own path to explore our language and rituals of being Chinese. Our paths, instead, come through the filtration by the modern world, through bilingual subtitles of movies, diaspora films of Asian immigrants, and numerous family stories retold over video calls.

Like Orvil, I am learning from fragments and picking them up to build my own adaptations, rather than replicating historic rituals. And those fragments are still alive, still mine. In There There, inherited pain narrows what characters use to navigate the current native society on their own. The novel then shows how cultural continuity survives in cities by novel adaptation, of the internet of modern powwows. This is why the standard of traditional purity fails; it measures present people against fantasies of ended cultures. Orange, Luna, and Alexie teach that identity persists not because the past is intact, but because communities make meaning from what remains.

When Luna ends his essay by asking, “Hey, do you still want to be an Indian?”, there is a sense of endurance of whether one can still claim identity amid feelings of distortion and loss (Luna). For both Orange’s characters and for me, the answer is yes. Identity lives not in traditional purity, but in the persistence to keep finding meaning in what remains.

Works Cited

Luna, James A. “I’ve Always Wanted to Be an American Indian.” Art Journal, vol. 51, no. 3, 1992, p. 18, https://doi.org/10.2307/777344.

Orange, Tommy. There There. Toronto, Emblem Editions, 5 June 2018.

Potts, Rolf. ““Indian Education,” by Sherman Alexie.” Rolf Potts, 15 Nov. 2018, rolfpotts.com/indian-education-alexie/.

Beckerman, Hannah. “Tommy Orange: “There’s a Monolithic Version of What a Native American Is Supposed to Be.”” The Guardian, 30 June 2018, www.theguardian.com/books/2018/jun/30/tommy-orange-native-american-novelist-interview-there-there.