Literary analysis / Dominican Republic

The Rabbit, the China, and the Dictator

On Julia Alvarez’s In the Time of the Butterflies

Sara Wan

Early in Julia Alvarez’s In the Time of Butterflies, Minerva opens the cage for her pet rabbit. In her mind, the gesture marks liberation, but the rabbit thinks otherwise. The rabbit refusing to leave the cage – which ought to herald freedom – leaves Minerva bewildered by the creature she is so intent on setting free (Alvarez 11). The rabbit subverts the appealing, familiar progression from captivity to success in escape – a satisfying ending, one may argue. However, while an open door promises a satisfying ending, it lacks the challenges and distrust the creature inside carries. By revisiting the sisters’ childhood and juxtaposing Minerva’s urgency with Mamá’s uneasy accommodation alongside Dedé’s evolving grasp of political discourse, Alvarez explores how authority persists, sustained by people’s deep-seated desire for safety. The characters must learn to recognize the cages they have inherited – once misconstrued as protection. Through the women’s uneven responses, Alvarez shows that recognizing a cage does not undo the fears and habits that make it feel protective.

Alvarez chooses to begin her narrative when the girls are young. The intent reveals a form of childhood education that rendered Trujillo’s “goodness” similar to a divine, unquestionable virtue. Through Minerva’s astonishment, Álvarez demonstrates how loyalty, before ever becoming a political choice, transforms into a moral instinct. This triumph reveals how the regime embeds civilians like Minerva within Trujillo’s meticulously crafted moral and religious framework so that their realizations can begin to unfold as the story progresses. When young Minerva hears for the first time that Trujillo might be “doing bad things,” she responds with disbelief; the suggestion feels as impossible as hearing that “Jesus had slapped a baby,” or that their “Blessed Mother had not conceived Him the immaculate conception way” (17). The comparison reveals the regime’s successful, thorough sacralization of Trujillo that appeals to civilians, especially towards younger demographics whose worldviews have not yet been shaped. Minerva borrows the language of sacrilege to describe political wrongdoing. Her disbelief exposes an education that has made Trujillo’s goodness seem as unquestionable as divine goodness. By narrating the revelation through Minerva’s astonishment, Alvarez suggests how Minerva must question the belief that he can do no wrong – which, at this point of her life, feels like a disagreement with everything she is taught to trust. Moreover, Alvarez’s use of first-person narration strengthens this idea of a mindset incredibly difficult to change since it was rooted in early adolescence, delaying the reader’s satisfaction of watching a future revolutionary recognize a tyrant. Minerva’s forthcoming resistance is compelled to develop within a mind that initially supplies his defense.

Alvarez marks Minerva’s change in attitude subtly: Minerva describes her doubt towards the regime as a “china-crack of doubt” (17). Minerva’s awakening isn’t a single dramatic revelation, though this one account of suffering taints a worldview that once seemed beyond dispute. However, that slight hesitation is essential to her determination to change later, allowing doubt to coexist with loyalty. The image resists a convenient conversion scene in which the protagonist encounters a dramatic revelation that instantly transforms themselves. Alvarez begins to entertain criticism she once rejected outright.

Once Minerva’s understanding of protection fractures, Alvarez deepens that fracture by moving it into her body. As Minerva learns more about Trujillo at school through the story of Lina Lovaton, shortness of breath and pressure gather in her chest: “tight in her chest as if it couldn’t get out” (23). At first, she attributes the sensation to the cotton bandage she binds tightly around her developing breasts — a terrible bargain to suppress the visibility that has made Lina vulnerable. Yet the tightness eventually exceeds the bindings as an explanation, where she felt “the tightening in [her] chest even when [she] wasn’t wearing the bandages,” relocating the source of danger from Minerva’s body to the political danger surrounding it (23). At her age, changing the regime lies far beyond the means available, so her instinct turns toward self-erasure which appears more possible. Alvarez thus turns political fear into a bodily reflex: Trujillo’s regime proves most effective when it no longer needs to issue a command because Minerva has learned to police herself. What once appeared to offer protection – in reality, increasingly reveals itself as the very system producing her fear. Soon, as she realizes that removing the cloth cannot remove the danger, the same visceral fear would help her recognize something her initial solution could not acknowledge – that the threat originates beyond her own body.

Read through that bodily fear, the earlier rabbit scene becomes much less comfortable, exposing cruelty within a seemingly nostalgic, innocent scene. Minerva recoils from the rabbit, insisting that it is “nothing at all like [her],” but her own attempt to find safety through restriction troubles the distinction (11). She can resent a cage yet still reach for the binding. Moreover, the rabbit’s refusal exposes a limit in her sympathy. She keeps slapping it to make it leave, until she recognizes that “[She] was the one hurting her, insisting she be free” (11). The sentence briefly makes the would-be liberator responsible for pain. Her desire to free the rabbit gives her no reliable knowledge of its fear; even more, she identifies her own cruelty along the way of distancing herself from the frightened creature. Even Minerva struggles to accept the implications of what she sees and how she treats them; transformation is never an automatic gift, only one beside denial and recognition. Meanwhile, Mamá’s uneasy compromise may give this fear a distinctly tangible shape.

Mamá gives that fear a human presence, as her accommodation of her husband’s infidelity cannot be explained by happiness or ignorance. During the pilgrimage, she includes him to strengthen her condemnation of men, telling her daughters, “…your father, too” (57). The admission interrupts the children’s usual readiness to exempt Papá from wrongdoing. Mamá perceives betrayal, yet she chooses to remain in a marriage already ravaged by it. Her discontent, though, undermines the equation of staying with consenting. Different from Minerva’s china, which signifies a dramatic shift in judgment, Mamá’s situation suggests how awareness and reluctant endurance can coexist within a single life. When considered alongside Minerva’s physical self-preservation, Mamá’s compromise gives rise to a question far more profound than whether or not she perceives the truth: how does one seek a sense of security within a relationship that one knows will cause personal harm?

Yet, Mamá’s distrust of her husband does not shield her from propaganda. When the newspapers label Lío a “communist,” she recoils, despite having previously identified with his ideas. Her protest: “But I didn't know they were communist ideas!” illustrates how a label can take precedence over genuine personal contact and exchange (74). The ideas themselves have not changed, but once branded with a new name, her former alignment with them suddenly becomes terrifying. Alvarez vividly portrays how propaganda infiltrates domestic conversation, because in this process, out of concern for their daughters, individuals end up acting as “enforcers” of the boundaries drawn by the state. Mama’s reaction reveals a gap where holding a critical perspective is one thing, but accepting the dangerous label attached to that perspective within the public sphere is quite another.

Mamá allowed an official label to take precedence over her own impressions of Lío; Dedé, by contrast, weighed her own direct observations against that label, deliberating on other sources she is willing to trust. She, too, has associated “communist” and “subversive” with criminality, yet Lío’s “lofty ideals and compassionate heart” undermine the character those words promise (75). Faced with the contradiction, Dedé begins to question who benefits from calling someone like Lío an enemy. Consequently, she arrives at the realization the Lío she knows does not resemble the “enemy of state” the government has taught her to expect (75). Faced with the mismatch, Dedé eventually begins to distrust the categorization. By placing Mamá’s recoil beside Dedé’s reconsideration, Alvarez makes the same information produce different judgements, for encountering Lío does not carry a lesson that everyone must receive in the same way – Dedé decides what authority to grant her own experience. Dedé reaches the same intellectual rupture as Minerva, just by a different route. In both cases, lived experience strips propaganda of its claim to truth.

Even with this rupture, however, recognition leaves the question of action unresolved. Dedé’s changed perspective does not commit her to following Minerva’s course exactly; just as Mamá’s compromises do not erase the discontent she harbors within. Through these scenes, Alvarez distinguishes between the ability to recognize injustice and the capacity to envision and undertake an alternative course of action. Minerva’s response to danger reveals the same difficulty: when she first senses danger, her initial response is to limit her own actions, to police herself. Fear, while sharpening her perceptions, simultaneously narrows the scope of her choices. The multiple perspectives presented in the novel ensure that the revolutionary identity Minerva ultimately assumes does not become the sole yardstick by which the awareness of these women is measured. Their varied ways of coping showcase the extent to which power has permeated daily choices.

The rabbit’s open cage door serves as a disquieting framework for the sisters’ political awakening. While the door may be open, the creatures within have yet to learn how to trust this newfound openness. The characters, however, show how a similar, inherited protection of one like the cage loses its credibility. Mama makes room for a painful realization of betrayal and one that can coexist with endurance, while Dedé demonstrates how to look beyond the labels imposed by authority to form independent judgments. Minerva’s intense drive lends urgency to her longing for freedom; yet her encounter with a rabbit reveals the harm that arises when such urgency leads her to make decisions for others. Read alongside Mamá’s endurance and Dedé’s reconsideration, the rabbit’s refusal leaves the reader asking what makes an open door feel dangerous.