Creative Nonfiction
Please Don’t Say It, Fred
“I wonder when the last time I got laid” was the one sentence I carried home from Thanksgiving. My Gruncle Fred said it somewhere between the stuffing and the sweet potatoes, in front of the pre-K twins and most of my dad’s side of the family. For a second everyone stared at him, but soon half the table covered their mouths and started laughing. Nobody wanted to picture old Fred – beer stomach and the Velcro sneakers – in the same sentence as the word sex.
“Why’s everyone so antiquated?” he asked.
I laughed into my napkin. Fred, not now. Fred, my baby brother is here. Fred, save it for your therapist. Instead, the question stayed there between the cranberry sauce and my grandmother’s china.
We call him Gruncle Fred, although he isn’t actually my great-uncle. He isn’t related to us at all, nor is he of Chinese heritage. He is an old friend of my dad’s who’s been around long enough that “family friend” stopped sounding right. Somehow, he became Gruncle; I don’t remember exactly when.
Fred remembers Yale very well, almost as if everything was back to normal again. When he thinks of Yale, he can remember everything. He remembers his fraternity brothers. He remembers being, as he likes to remind us, a Yale man. Most importantly, he remembers the Vassar girls. There are apparently a lot of them.
“Don’t say it, Fred,” I tell him whenever I can see another story coming.
He says it anyway.
I have heard some of them enough times that I know where he will pause and where my dad will roll his eyes. I’d do that thing on TV where a character, obviously frustrated, mouths the story while the other is oblivious to the repetition and says it again and again. Sometimes the details of his story change. Sometimes a girl gets prettier. Sometimes there are two girls where I could have sworn there used to be one.
My cousin laughed at Thanksgiving and said Fred probably couldn’t remember the last time he got laid anyway.
“No kids of his own,” she added.
I gave her a look.
“What?” she said. “It’s not like he’s going to remember it.”
Fred was busy telling my dad something about New Haven and didn’t hear her. Lately, the old stories have become strangely reliable. Yesterday disappears, but Yale rarely does. Ask him what he had for breakfast and you might get a shrug, but mention Vassar, I tell you – the room will fill up with beautiful women.
For a while, I found this funny, but it soon became too repetitive. He repeats himself. In his head, he thinks he is telling the story for the first time because that’s how Alzheimer’s wants to remember it. There are afternoons when patience feels less noble than people make it sound, and I catch irritation rising before I have time to stop it. Then I feel guilty for the rest of the day.
Fred is the ultimate uncle someone will have. Even with the crutches now, he still seems unmistakably Fred. Just that sometimes doesn’t see me as unmistakably Sara. He smiles at me only sometimes, and when he does, blankly. He doesn’t remember me anymore. Fred isn’t this uncanny guy who says inappropriate jokes whenever he wants to. I think it’s mostly because he doesn’t remember any other time in his life that he can share, nor does he realize it has been more than thirty years.
I smile back.
“Who are you?” He asks, blankly. I don’t see anything in his eyes. It’s scary sometimes.
I remind him, again and again. Sometimes, a few minutes later, we are talking normally again. Maybe Yale comes up.
I used to think remembering somebody was very mutual. I know you; you know me. of the fundamental rules of human interaction. One of the easiest ways you can feel connection. I remember enough for both of us now.