Personal Essays
The Unsaid Troubles of Blind Spots
American cartoons have no patience with nuance: an Angel and Devil materialize on the shoulders of characters facing a dilemma. Should Sylvester eat Tweety Bird, or not?
My shoulder sitters are tiny old men with beards. Confucius, a legacy of my East Asian upbringing, urges harmony and caution, reminding me of the fragility of human pride. Whitman arrived later, through studying American individualism at boarding school: “I sound my barbaric yawp over the roofs of the world!” Cue Confucius eye roll.
At Carnegie Mellon’s pre-college program, I was a writing student producing an original film, feeling nearly invisible among effortlessly chic art and music students. Then, from that intimidating species, I spotted Him.
His insouciance was the embodiment of the Older Brother character I had spent weeks imagining. Ignoring Confucius, who seemed to be muttering that normal people do not walk up to strangers and say, Excuse me, you belong in my mental-health drama, I quickened my pace and tapped him on the shoulder.
“I think you’re really cool,” I blurted, a humiliatingly uncool phrase. His friends snickered.
Whitman hissed, “Ignore them! The worst has happened. Plunge ahead.”
“Can I have your email so I can tell you about a role in my film?”
Probably out of pity, he gave it to me.
When I discovered he was a design student with no acting experience, I built a visual-heavy pitch deck for a character who was essentially him, complete with spiked hair and smudged eyeliner. I ended with an offer I considered irresistible: “You’ll hardly have any lines.”
He accepted.
As a first-time producer-director, I initially treated filmmaking like constructing a miniature universe. I had written the script, imagined the rooms, chosen the angles, decided when somebody entered and when somebody left. Behind the camera, I occupied the peculiar position of a giant looking down on a world small enough to fit inside a frame. I knew where every character was supposed to stand. More dangerously, I thought I knew what every character was supposed to feel.
Whitman approved. Creativity, I assumed, meant persuading reality to resemble the picture in my head.
That confidence lasted until I had to direct an actual human being. As a first-time producer/director, I leaned heavily into Whitman, approaching creativity as an act of sheer will, persuading the world to cooperate with my plans. But conveying my artistic vision to an aloof non-actor proved challenging. Simple instructions like “Act guilty” produced almost nothing.
My actor would stare at me with the calm expression of someone being asked to impersonate a weather system and looking for an explosion. I was unable to appreciate his portrayal of a person shutting down and becoming ice-cold, a rage infinitely more menacing.
Confucius cleared his throat: “Impatience in small matters confounds the execution of great goals!” So, I changed tactics. Instead of naming emotions, I gave him situations.
“You’re cooking because it’s your cover for hiding your mother’s vase that you just broke,” I told him. “You’re holding an apology in your mouth and refusing to open it.”
He considered this, nodded, and nailed the scene. For a while, I congratulated myself. The giant had merely learned how to issue better instructions to the tiny inhabitants below.
Then we reached a scene requiring fury, and I knew exactly what anger looked like in my head. It contained a raised voice – something volcanic. But after several takes, none of it appeared.
Waltman hinted I should yawp at him to hasten the process. Confucius counseled, “The wise man speaks low and listens much.”
Finally, instead of giving another direction, I asked, “What’s happening for you in this scene?”
He shrugged. “When I’m angry, I get quiet.”
Somewhere in my mind, I wanted to correct him. The scene was mine. The character was mine. I had spent months building his history, his relationships, even the emotional temperature of the room. From my position behind the camera, I could see the entire little universe at once.
Or I thought I could.
“Okay,” I said. “Let’s see it again.”
He performed the scene almost motionlessly. His shoulders stiffened, and his responses became clipped and painfully calm. I had been waiting for fire, but he gave me ice.
Watching the playback, I realized that I had mistaken authorship for omniscience. Because I had built the world, I assumed everyone inside it had to exist according to my proportions. Yet the actor standing inside my imaginary universe could see something about my own character that I could not.
For the first time, being the “giant” behind the camera felt like a limitation. From above, I could arrange the furniture, control and decide where the frame began and ended, but I had come to realize that scale can distort perception. Sometimes the person standing inside the scene knows its emotional geography better than the person towering over it.
The discovery changed the way I directed the rest of the film. I still arrived with my tripod, my plans, shot lists, prop lists, and highly specific opinions. However, I began leaving cracks in the world I had constructed – spaces where an actor could disagree with me, where an accident could become better than an intention. I came to forgive myself that, sometimes, another person’s interpretation could enlarge something I thought I had already finished. I stopped beating myself up about it.
Confucius and Whitman still share space on my shoulders, but they don’t direct me.
I listen while they argue, trust my instincts, and leave room for an outcome none of us envisioned.