Academic Essays / Area of Research

Games of Awakening: Navigating the Terrain of Social Discovery in Emma

Literary analysis

Sara Wan · 2,590 words in the essay

“It was badly done, indeed!” exclaimed Mr. Knightley after Emma once again overstepped the boundaries of social banter (Austen 303). Mr. Knightley utilizes the simplicity of this phrase to reflect the severity of Emma’s repeated offense, critiquing the seriousness of the misstep Emma has just committed, and to confront the harm caused when social games come in at the expense of human dignity and respect.

In Austen’s Emma, readers are introduced to the Regency Era, in which society seems to be perpetually described as a setting where “A man always imagines a woman to be ready for anybody who asks her,” showcasing a setting where one’s availability and appearances are constantly interpreted (47). Characters are often arranged to socialize in the realm of courtship, particularly under the playful hands of our main protagonist Emma Woodhouse, who is always “having rather too much her own way,” and often thinks “a little too well of herself” (1). These characteristics lead us along with Emma’s journey of social gamesmanship in her social circle, seemingly innocent, yet fraught with emotional risks. What began as amusement often ended as unintended harm, and were “the disadvantages which threatened alloy to [Emma’s] many enjoyments” (1). Such subtle flaws threaten Emma’s rich and clever nature; in a manner where her boredom and overconfidence often spoil the happiness of others as she treats courtship to her as a game, one that is unknowingly overplayed, and detrimental to those around her. Austen characterizes matchmaking as “the greatest amusement in the world” to Emma Woodhouse, utilizing the metaphor of game to critique Emma’s treatment of courtship as a harmless game meant for casual amusement. Emma’s initial social misjudgment of others and lack of emotional intelligence reveal her tendency to treat others’ relationships as if they are strategic moves in a game. However, as the consequences of her interventions unfold, she is ultimately reckoned to come to terms with facing the consequences of controlling others’ social lives, becoming a humbled participant in her own.

Emma’s matching-making efforts can be traced back to the roots of pride and misjudgement of social gain instead of empathy and recognition for others. Emma’s assures her father in the first chapter, expressing she has no intentions of marriage but she must make matches for others: “I promise you to make none for myself, papa; but I must, indeed, for other people” introduces the thought that she will stay single but must make matches for others (6). The usage of the word “must” suggests that she almost feels the need to be entitled to intervene with others’ romantic relationships, ignorant of the emotional risks, where she doesn’t yet understand courtship is more than a game of puzzles to be solved but rather a pursuit of genuine connection. This conversation foreshadows the inflated belief of Emma’s interpretation of love and overconfidence in her own ability of matchmaking; this belief is then promptly explored in depth during several following scenes where Austen carries readers into romantic gameplay conducted by Emma. This scene of gameplay, which occurs at Hartfield, interacts Emma with one of her most noteworthy matchmaking target and mentee, Harriet Smith. While the Emma and Harriet engage in a charades game with the vicar of Highbury, Mr. Elton, Emma imagines herself skillfully guiding a future romance between Harriet and Mr. Elton as the charades game begins, assuming she has interpreted signs of affection through the undertones of Mr. Elton’s riddle, reading: “My first displays the wealth and pomp of kings... / Lord of the earth and sea, he bends a slave, / And woman, lovely woman, reigns alone” (56). Emma is convinced that Mr. Elton uses the term “lovely woman” to pay tribute and show interest to Harriet, where in reality, Mr. Elton was attempting to confess his romantic pursuit by praise directed towards Emma herself (Colleen A. Sheehan). Emma further mocks Harriet’s struggles to solve this charade, dismissing her answers and regarding them as overly literal, such as “Neptune,” or “Trident,” being overly simplistic, ridiculing Harriet for her inability to comprehend the riddle (Colleen A. Sheehan). This moment further highlights Emma’s lack of emotional intelligence that is replaced by her pursuit towards game wit, as she falls short of recognizing Harriet’s vulnerability. Furthermore, the meaning of the riddle itself initially recognizes masculine power; where the phrase “lords of the earth,” and “monarch of the seas” ends with man dethroned, rendered a “slave” to “lovely woman” (56). On the surface, Mr. Elton’s presentation is to celebrate feminine beauty by first establishing a world under masculine dominance, with a following contrast to an unexpected idea of social hierarchy, where women hold power over men (“The Vehicle for Gallantry and Trick”: Educating Emma’s Readers”). The usage of the word “king” marks a literal symbol of masculine power, ruling over land, people, and law. Further, the term “lord” evokes the grandeur and authority traditionally associated with male power, where one with such a name has total domination in land and geography. The phrase “bends a slave” further emphasizes a coercive strength to masculine rule; one doesn’t just rule, but bends others according to his will (56). Yet in the final line, “And woman, lovely woman, reigns alone,” this hierarchy is suddenly reversed; the dominant man becomes emotionally following to a woman, not through reason or equality, but through her loveliness and romantic allure (56). Mr. Elton’s riddle outwardly praises women over men in terms of status, ignoring the current social norms of the era, where men are typically assumed to hold higher power than women (“The Vehicle for Gallantry and Trick”: Educating Emma’s Readers”). His flatters all lead to the central idea of where the woman rules over the man, reflecting the idealization of woman not discerning reputation by fame or reputation, but through emotional and romantic influence. Mr. Elton attempts to impress Emma by using this riddle to show his respect for women, this gesture purposely utilized to directly flatter Emma. Emma, on the other hand, misinterprets the target of the flattering completely by thinking it’s his confession of feelings and praise towards Harriet. Emma believes there is a “pointed” and “particular meaning in this compliment” which leads her to not even “have a doubt as to Mr. Elton’s intentions,” where in truth be told, Emma is terribly mistaken by the true meanings behind Mr. Elton’s hints (58). These intermixing thoughts through the conversation between the characters shows how Emma imposes her own matchmaking ideas and places them onto Mr. Elton’s words and actions with quick assumptions, presuming that his attention is to Harriet rather than towards Emma herself. It is not until when Mr. Elton brings up the answer to this riddle being “courtship”–an intentional omission signifying that he is not interested in engaging in wit–when Emma realizes Mr. Elton, in reality, is expressing a motive to commit in courtship with Emma. This riddle exhibits itself as a move in the larger social game of courtship, where the selfish choice of Emma to seek honest feelings between her friends is overcome by her playfulness and personal intentions to complete her planned “task” of successful matchmaking. Austen here indicates that Emma is solely focused on her internal ambitions instead of a hope for genuine romance by portraying a series of misdirections from herself to others, overarching the surface she perceives. Austen further implies that the game of courtship Emma is playing should truly be a reality that requires mutual recognition between two individuals, where at this point of the book, Emma is still yet to learn.

Yet even after the recognition of her first social misplay, Emma’s growth is uneven; she has not yet fully abandoned the social pleasure from manipulating others’ relationships in a world built on matchmaking games and impulsive assumptions. This theme of lacking emotional insight and treating courtship with such frivolity builds tension in the Box Hill scene later in Emma. Frank Churchill initiates another public game involving the main characters of the novel, gathered in an outing at Box Hill, as Churchill challenges everyone to say “​​one thing very clever,” or “two things moderately clever,” or “three very dull things indeed.” (299). Humbled and good-natured, Miss Bates self-deprecatingly responds that she “need not to be uneasy,” and that she “shall be sure to say three dull things as soon as ever,” (299). This indicates that Miss Bates holds a belief where she can easily say three very dull things without much thought, in a tone where she is lowering her own status to maintain social harmony while creating a humble image. Emma, who “could not resist” the moment for mockery, seizes the opportunity to joke, “Pardon me—but you will be limited as to number—only three at once,” implying Miss. Bates is so dull that it would be quite easy for her to frequently exceed the limit of three very dull things (299). Miss Bates, for whom status and dignity portrays her method of survival in the social aspect, Miss Bates is clearly humiliated publicly: “deceived by the mock ceremony of [Emma’s] manner” (299). Emma is now set forth as a character who is uncertain of her inappropriate encouragement towards the loss of dignity, survival, and a well-natured social image of a woman like Miss Bates. Emma’s thoughtless mockery is not merely unpleasant but socially severe, exposing her emotional immaturity and failure to understand the realities of the social world she treats as a game. What she sees as a lighthearted joke can be a humiliating insult to others, uncovering an insensitivity to the precarious positions of those around her simultaneously, particularly those like Miss Bates. Austen appeals to the audience of Emma’s inability to catch sight of different treatments toward social interaction: where Emma treats social interaction as a game of wit, others may be playing for dignity and survival. Austen then juxtaposes two distinct ways of handling social awkwardness in the aftermath of this conversation: Emma, on one hand, who does not realize she has treated Miss Bates’s harmless jokes as a game for ridicule, and Mr. Knightley, who steps in to restore moral dignity. Mr. Knightly, contrasted to Emma’s insensitivity to take insight on what is game and what is not, inquiries Emma how could she “be so unfeeling to Miss Bates?” and how “insolent in [Emma’s] wit” she was to a woman with Miss Bates “character, age, and situation,” carefully balancing the social tension by rebuking Emma’s unpleasant mockery (302). He steps in firmly not just to defend Miss Bates, but to expose the immoral and insensitive approach behind Emma’s behavior. He reminds Emma that between Miss Bates and her stands a divergent social status, and Emma has “sunk from the comforts she was born to” while educating Emma that instead of viewing the situation as a game, Miss Bates is in a “condition should guarantee [Emma’s] sympathy” (303). Mr. Knightley’s understanding towards Miss Bates distinguishes from Emma’s judgemental mockery for seeing status as a shield for playful judgment, as he is clear between what may be tolerable in such a situation for the prosperous to what can become cruel in the shoes of the vulnerable. “Were she a fortune,” he concedes to Emma, “I would not quarrel with you for any liberties of manners,” reminding Emma that Miss Bates’ likely social descent in the future “should secure [Emma’s] compassion,” not her contempt (303). Mr. Knightley portrays the character to critique those who confuse high social status without understanding how much power one can only hold, like Emma, who has been called attention to her ignorance to the emotional risks in her game of social wit. Mr. Knightley’s actions to intervene are more than just personal respect to Miss Bates, but more to the ethical morals of society and to see beyond the comfort of the self, acknowledging the limitations of others. Austen further secures the idea of Emma’s penchant in handling relationships as foolish games–those that seem to help her envision this realm of cleverness and calculation of guidance–exposes the inability from her to read emotions accurately, leading to miscalculations that harm relationships between others. Now, for the first time, Emma comes to realize that she is facing the moral failure embedded in her habitual gamesmanship. Emma’s belated consciousness to the social severity of her thoughtless play marks her realization that her once supposed amusement has been replaced by unfavorable harm. Here, Austen uses the trope of game to dramatize how the advantaged may, in hurtful ways, play at the expense of the vulnerable, whether intentionally or not. After reflecting on her actions, Emma begins to consider the real effects of her social performances and feels genuine remorse, being never “so depressed” (304). Her thought of the wretchedness at Box Hill prompts her to visit Miss Bates to offer a sincere apology (304). By this point, Emma has understood that she is not visiting out of social obligation but rather as a recognition of the harm done. Emma’s shift in her social consciousness is unveiled as she transitions from gambling with courtship as a game to reflectively viewing it as a matter of moral obligation involving real emotional risks.

Through Emma’s multiple failures and journey on the discovery of thoughtful social play and human dignity; Austen parallels Emma’s transformed self from the thoughtless, overly-confident individual to an awakened young woman in emotional intelligence; she begins to comprehend that social life, in love especially, cannot be played as a game at the expense of the vulnerable, for it is a mutual recognition that plays the key to genuine happiness. In this same train of thought, she further reflects her own experience with Mr. Knightley’s love. Despite all the quarrels over Harriet, Mr. Knightley is “faultless in spite of all [Emma’s] faults” (348), exhibiting the depth of love and ability to see beyond Emma’s flaws, a pivotal moment in Emma’s growth emotionally as she begins to realize the value of self-awareness and humility in relationships. By Mr. Knightley heartfelt expressions of love: “If I loved you less, I might be able to talk about it,” Emma began to understand the sincere significance of human connection, and abandons the idea of love that formerly governed her conduct: her once performative wit and passion for uncalled gamesmanship to strive for emotional intelligence (346). The schemed games that once defined her interactions and matchmaking standards in the end lead to her thinking courtship is a “game,” and therefore, ends in the humbling realization that real love needs humility and sincere human connection, not the sense of accomplishment after a plotted success in matchmaking.

For Emma Woodhouse, matchmaking once was a witty gamble, but Austen challenges readers to understand the high emotional and social stakes beneath the lighthearted surfaces of social banter. She emphasizes the idea that healthy interactions arise from awakenings to social connections by self-examination and viewing social connections with empathy and thoughtfulness–for neither socializing nor connections is ever a game, nor is there victory. Instead, it is a reflective process of the flawed nature of humanity. In this light, addressing the trope of game is essential to understanding Emma, for it is revealed how easily various approaches to social settings can give onto powerful relationships. By illustrating Emma’s shift in her approaches to social settings from the overly-confident orchestrator to a modest participant, Austen ensures the idea of socializing not as a game but as a navigating human process of learning connection. For Emma, the end of the “game” is not victory, but an awakening: to humility, empathy, and the true meaning of social relationships.

Works Cited

Austen, Jane. Emma (Wordsworth Classics). 9 Jan. 2023.

“Colleen A. Sheehan.” Jasna.org, jasna.org/persuasions/on-line/vol27no1/sheehan.htm.

‌“The Vehicle for Gallantry and Trick”: Educating Emma’s Readers.” Jasna.org, 2016, jasna.org/publications-2/essay-contest-winning-entries/2016/educating-emmas-readers